We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
The catch rule in football has created more debates than almost any other rule. Fans shout at the TV. Players throw up their hands. Even experienced coaches hold their breath during replays. Why is it so hard? Because a “catch” is not just grabbing the ball. It is a sequence with specific steps, different possibilities, and a few tricky edge cases. In this guide, we will walk through the catch rule in clear, simple language, with real-world examples and easy tips for watching plays live. By the end, you will feel confident explaining what is and is not a catch to anyone sitting next to you on game day.
The Big Picture: What Counts as a Catch?
At its core, a catch is about control, location, and time. In the NFL today, a forward-pass catch happens when a player:
1) Secures control of the ball, 2) gets two feet (or another body part) in bounds, and 3) performs a “football move” or has time to do so. If the player is going to the ground while trying to catch, he must keep control through contact with the ground unless he has already become a runner. That sounds like a lot, but it becomes much easier when you break it into parts.
Control: What It Is and What It Isn’t
Control means the player firmly secures the ball with his hands or arms. If the ball is still moving around or being bobbled, he does not have control yet. Control can begin even if the ball is not hugged tightly to the chest. Pinning the ball against the body, helmet, or forearm can count as control, as long as the player is actually holding it and the ball is not sliding around. Slight movement of the ball is allowed as long as the player never loses firm control.
Common confusion: people often think any ball movement means no catch. That is not correct. The key question is whether the player loses control. If he keeps his hands on the ball and it shifts but never comes loose, control can still be intact.
Two Feet or Another Body Part in Bounds
In the NFL, the player must get two feet in bounds. A toe tap with both feet counts. Dragging the second foot counts. Knees, elbows, hips, or the buttocks also count—any of those can replace the second foot. What does not count is a hand. If a player controls the ball, lands with one foot in bounds and then places a hand down in bounds before stepping out, that is not enough.
Out of bounds lines are part of “out.” If any part of the foot touches the white sideline or end line before getting two feet or a body part in bounds with control, the pass is incomplete. Officials often watch the toe tips and heel shadows very closely on replay because a single blade of turf can decide the call.
The “Football Move” or Time Element
After control and two feet (or another body part), the player needs to complete an act common to the game—a “football move.” This is the step that helps separate a completed catch from a fleeting touch. A football move can be any of the following:
– A third step after the two feet. – Tucking the ball away. – Turning upfield. – Reaching or extending the ball. – Having the ability to ward off a defender. – Having the time to take such an action, even if the player is hit before he clearly does it.
This part trips people up. You do not always need a clear third step if there is obvious control, two feet, and enough time to make a move. On the other hand, if the player is hit immediately after the second foot and the ball pops loose before any act common to the game, it can be ruled incomplete.
Going to the Ground: The Toughest Part
Many controversies come from plays where a receiver dives or is falling as he tries to catch. The rule handles these situations differently than plays where the receiver is already upright and clearly becomes a runner.
When the Ground Is Part of the Play
If a receiver is going to the ground while trying to make the catch, he must maintain control of the ball all the way through the landing. If the ball touches the ground and that contact causes the ball to move enough that he loses control, it is incomplete. If the ball touches the ground but the player maintains firm control without the ball coming loose, the catch can still be good.
Think of it this way: if the fall is part of the process of catching, you have to “finish the catch” on the ground. If the player had already become a runner before going to the ground, then the ground can cause a fumble instead. That is the key difference—receiver vs. runner—at the exact moment he hits the ground.
Becoming a Runner
A player becomes a runner once he completes the catch (control + two feet/body part) and performs, or has time to perform, a football move. At that point, the play shifts from “trying to complete a catch” to “running with the ball.” When a runner goes to the ground, the ball can come out and be ruled a fumble, as long as no knee or elbow down ended the play first.
Example: A receiver catches a slant, takes two steps, tucks the ball, and then dives forward. He has become a runner. If the ball pops out when he hits the ground without contact, it is a fumble. If he never tucked the ball, got hit as the second foot came down, and then the ball came loose on contact with the ground, that likely remains incomplete because he had not become a runner.
Ball Movement When Hitting the Ground
The ball can move when the player hits the ground. Loose movement alone is not enough to wipe out the catch if the player maintains control. If the ball visibly shifts and clearly slips away from the hands or arms—and the player needs to re-secure it—then control is lost. This is where high-frame-rate replays matter. Officials look for clear evidence that the player never let the ball get away from his hands or against his body.
Sideline, End Zone, and Pylons
Where a catch happens can change how it is judged. Plays at the sideline, in the end zone, and near the pylon bring special details.
Sideline Catches
On the sideline, the footwork is everything. The receiver must control the ball and get two feet in bounds before any part of him touches out. The classic toe-tap is the gold standard: tap one toe, drag the other across the green, and exit out of bounds after that. If the heel drops out while the toe is still on the turf, replay will check whether the in-bounds foot ever fully left the ground. A dragging toe that brushes green counts as a step in bounds even if it is barely visible.
If the player bobbles the ball while the feet hit in bounds but only secures control after stepping out, it is incomplete. Control must happen before or while the in-bounds footwork is completed.
End Zone Catches and Touchdowns
To score, the receiver must complete the catch in the end zone. That means control, two feet or a body part, and the time element or football move—or continued control if he is going to the ground in the process. The moment those conditions are met, the play is over and it is a touchdown. The ground after that cannot cause an incompletion because the catch is already complete.
Important difference: For a runner carrying the ball, crossing the plane of the goal line with the ball in control ends the play immediately—touchdown—even if the ball comes out after crossing. For a receiver who is still in the act of catching when he hits the end zone, he must first complete the catch by the rule. If he is going to the ground and has not become a runner yet, he must maintain control through contact with the ground.
Pylons and the Goal Line Extended
The pylons are part of the goal line and the boundary. If a player is already a runner and reaches the ball inside or over the pylon while in control, it is a touchdown. For a catching receiver near the pylon, the same catch process applies: he must complete the catch with control and in-bounds status before he is out. If his first contact with the ground in control is on the pylon or out of bounds, it is not a catch.
Incomplete vs. Fumble: The Line Between
When a pass hits hands and then hits the ground, people instantly ask, “Is it incomplete or a fumble?” The difference is whether the catch was ever completed before the ball came out.
How Officials Decide
Officials run through a sequence on every play: Did the player secure control? Did he get two feet or a body part in bounds? Did he perform a football move or have time to do so? If the answer to those is yes, the catch is complete. If the ball comes loose after that, it is a fumble unless the player was down by contact.
If the answer to any of those steps is no, it is incomplete. If the receiver was still going to the ground in the act of catching and lost control when he hit, that is incomplete—not a fumble—because the catch never finished.
Examples to Make It Clear
Example 1: A receiver catches a hitch route, takes three steps, tucks the ball, and a defender strips it. That is a catch and a fumble.
Example 2: A receiver leaps, gets two feet down in the air while being hit, and the ball pops free as he lands because he never tucked it. That is most often incomplete because he had not performed a football move or had time to do so, and he was going to the ground during the process of the catch.
Example 3: A receiver controls the ball, gets two feet down, stretches for the pylon, and loses the ball at the pylon after clearly tucking and reaching. That is a catch and a fumble out of bounds in the end zone (a touchback) if it goes forward and out of the end zone. Painful, but by rule correct if the catch was complete and he was a runner.
Interceptions and Simultaneous Catches
Defensive players must follow the same catch rule as receivers when they intercept a pass. Control, in-bounds feet or body part, and the time element apply on interceptions as well.
Defensive Catches Follow the Same Steps
If a defender picks the ball off with firm control, gets two feet down, and tucks it, it is an interception. If he is going to the ground while making the pick, he must maintain control through the landing unless he has already become a runner.
Simultaneous Catch Goes to the Offense
If a receiver and a defender gain control of the ball at the same time and come down together with joint control, the ball is awarded to the offense as a completed catch. However, true simultaneous control is rare. Often, replay can find that one player had control first or that one lost control during the landing. The on-field ruling and the replay standard will matter a lot here.
Tipped and Bobbled Balls
A forward pass that touches a player remains live until it hits the ground. Receivers can tip the ball to themselves. Teammates can catch it after a deflection. The only hard stop is the ground; once it touches the turf before control, the pass is incomplete and the play is dead. If a receiver briefly loses grip, regains control before the ball hits the ground, and gets his feet in bounds, the catch can still be good.
College and High School Differences
Many fans watch both college and pro games and get mixed up. Here are the key differences that matter most to viewers.
Feet Down: One vs. Two
In college (NCAA) and most high school rules (NFHS), a receiver needs only one foot (or one body part like a knee) in bounds with control to complete a catch. In the NFL, it is two feet or a body part equivalent to two feet (like a knee and an elbow). This is why college toe-taps look a bit easier. One toe in bounds can be enough. That is the biggest and most visible difference.
Going to the Ground
The concept of maintaining control to the ground exists in college and high school, too. If a player is falling while making the catch and the ball comes loose when he hits the ground, it is incomplete in all codes unless he had already clearly completed the catch and become a runner. The wording can vary by rule book, but the idea is the same: finish the process if the ground is part of the catch.
Force-Out
In both the NFL and NCAA today, “force-out” does not save a catch on a forward pass. If a receiver is airborne and contacted by a defender and lands out of bounds without getting the required foot or feet down in bounds, it is incomplete. Years ago, the NFL used to have a force-out rule on some catches, but that is no longer the case.
Replay and Consistency
The NFL has centralized replay with many camera angles. College replay varies by conference and broadcast quality. High school rarely has replay. Sometimes a play in a college game looks like a catch to you but is ruled differently in the NFL. Often, that difference comes down to the feet requirement or replay certainty, not a fundamentally different concept of control.
A Short History: Why the Rule Changed
The NFL used to use the phrase “survive the ground,” which made sense to some fans but caused endless confusion. Several famous plays pushed the league to simplify the rule.
Calvin Johnson, 2010
Calvin Johnson appeared to catch a game-winner for the Lions. He controlled the ball, got both feet down, and put the ball on the ground while getting up. The ball moved, and officials ruled it incomplete because he had not “survived the ground” during the catch process. Fans were outraged, and the play became a teaching clip for years.
Dez Bryant, 2014
In the playoffs, Dez Bryant made a spectacular leaping grab near the goal line for the Cowboys. He extended the ball toward the goal line as he landed, and the ball moved when it hit the ground. Under the old interpretation, officials ruled it incomplete. Many fans believed he had made a football move by reaching, and that should have ended the catch. This moment kept the debate burning.
Jesse James, 2017
Late in a game, Steelers tight end Jesse James caught a pass near the goal line, reached to break the plane, and the ball moved as he hit the ground. Ruling: incomplete. This was a turning point. The following offseason, the NFL simplified the catch rule, placing more focus on control, feet, and a football move, and less on complicated survival language.
Today’s Simpler Standard
Under the modern standard, if a player controls the ball, gets two feet down, and makes a football move—like taking a third step or reaching—the catch is complete. If the player was still going to the ground while completing the catch, he must maintain control through the ground unless he had already become a runner. This is simpler to apply, and it has reduced controversial calls, even if debates still pop up now and then.
Practical Checklist for Watching Live
When you watch a play in real time, run a quick mental checklist. First, look at the hands: does the player truly secure the ball, or is it still bobbling? Second, snap your eyes to the feet: did he get two in bounds (NFL) or at least one (college) before stepping out? Third, think about time: did he take a third step, tuck, or otherwise show control long enough to do something football-like? If yes to all three, it is almost always a catch. If the player is diving or falling, ask whether the ground is part of the catch. If the ball moves and the player re-secures only after it hits the ground, it is incomplete.
Why Some Calls Take So Long
Officials must piece together angles: one angle for control, another for feet, and sometimes a third for the time element or the ball touching the ground. The ruling on the field matters too; replay needs clear and obvious evidence to change it. If the images are not perfect, the call might stand even if you personally think it is the other way.
Common Myths and Misunderstandings
There are a few phrases that fans repeat that are not quite right. Clearing these up will make you a better judge of catches.
“If the ball moves at all, it’s incomplete.”
Not true. The ball can shift as long as the player maintains control. Losing control means the ball comes away from the hands or body and the player must re-secure it. Minor movement is allowed. What matters is sustained control, not perfect stillness.
“Two feet equals a catch, always.”
Two feet in bounds are necessary in the NFL but not always enough. You also need control and a football move or the time element. If a defender hits the receiver the instant the second foot lands and the ball pops out before any act common to the game, it can be incomplete.
“The end zone is different.”
For a runner, yes—breaking the plane ends the play. For a receiver still making the catch, no—he must finish the process the same as anywhere else on the field. If he is going to the ground in the end zone during the catch and loses control when he lands, it is incomplete.
“Any bobble kills the catch.”
A bobble before control is established means there is no catch yet. But a brief bobble that is secured with two feet in bounds can result in a catch if the rest of the elements are satisfied. Again, focus on when full control is gained and whether it ever gets lost.
How Replay Reviews Work on Catches
Replay is there to fix clear mistakes, not to re-officiate every tight call. The standard is “clear and obvious” to overturn. If the ruling on the field is a catch, the replay must show clear loss of control or a missed foot out of bounds to reverse it. If the ruling on the field is incomplete, replay must show a clear sequence of control, feet, and time (or a football move) to overturn.
Angles and Timing Matter
Often one camera shows control, another shows the sideline foot, and a third shows the ball grazing the ground. If any piece is not clearly visible, the call might stand. Inside the final two minutes and on scoring plays, the replay booth initiates reviews. Coaches can challenge outside of two minutes if they have challenges remaining and a timeout to risk.
“Call Stands” vs. “Confirmed”
Sometimes you will hear “the ruling on the field stands.” That means the replay did not have enough to be sure one way or the other. “Confirmed” means the replay clearly supported the original call. Understanding this difference explains many tight end-zone or sideline plays where fans disagree across living rooms.
Coaching and Player Techniques That Satisfy the Rule
Players practice specific techniques to help meet the standard the rule requires. Those same techniques also help you understand why certain plays look the way they do.
The Toe-Tap and Drag
Receivers are coached to get one foot down and then slide the second foot across the turf to leave visible rubber pellets or a clear drag line. That visual cue helps officials and replay. Even a light toe brush can be enough if it is in bounds and control is established.
Tuck Quickly to Become a Runner
After securing the ball and getting the feet down, receivers try to tuck the ball against the body fast. That tuck is a clear “football move” that helps complete the catch. If a defender hits immediately, a quick tuck can be the difference between incomplete and catch-fumble.
High-Pointing and Strong Hands
On jump balls, receivers try to high-point the ball and clamp it with strong hands, reducing bobbles. Pinning the ball against the chest right away increases control and makes the landing cleaner under the going-to-ground rule.
Sideline Awareness
Veteran receivers are constantly aware of the boundary. They will adjust their stride so the second foot can drag in bounds while securing control. Quarterbacks also throw the ball in places where a receiver can toe-tap behind the sideline.
Quick Scenarios and What the Rule Says
Scenario 1: A receiver leaps near the sideline, touches the ball, gets one foot down in bounds, bobbles, then secures full control while his second foot is already out. Ruling: incomplete. Control was not established before going out.
Scenario 2: A receiver catches a quick out, controls the ball, gets two feet down, and immediately turns upfield before being hit and losing the ball. Ruling: catch and fumble. He became a runner.
Scenario 3: A receiver dives in the end zone, secures the ball in his hands while airborne, the ball stays against his chest, he lands, the nose of the ball touches the ground but does not move or come loose. Ruling: touchdown. The ground did not cause a loss of control.
Scenario 4: A defender and receiver both grab the ball in the air, land together, and neither ever wrests it away from the other. Ruling: simultaneous catch—offense’s ball (interception denied) if it truly is simultaneous and not one player first.
Scenario 5: A receiver catches, taps both feet, and reaches the ball toward the goal line as he is hit; the ball crosses the plane but he loses control as he falls and was still in the process of the catch. Ruling: no touchdown, incomplete if he had not yet become a runner and failed to maintain control through the ground.
Scenario 6: A receiver goes up, pins the ball to his helmet, gets two feet down, and tucks as he is driven to the ground. Ruling: likely a catch once the tuck or third step happens; if the ball comes loose only after he had become a runner, it is a fumble.
Scenario 7: A receiver secures the ball, gets two feet, and has time to turn but is stripped before the third step. Ruling: could still be a catch-fumble if the time element was satisfied—even without the third step—if he had the opportunity to act common to the game.
Why Some Plays Still Spark Debate
Even with a simpler rule, football moves fast. Camera angles can be blocked. Hands can hide the ball for a split second. Was there truly a third step? Did the player have time to act? Did the ball just shift or actually come loose? Because of these gray areas, the ruling on the field often decides the outcome when replay evidence is not crystal clear. That is not a failure of the rule; it is a reality of a sport played at high speed with human officials and limited angles.
Tips for Teaching Friends and Family
Start with three questions: control, feet, and time. Point to the hands first. Then point to the feet on the replay. Then ask, “Did he do anything football-like before the ball came out?” If yes, it is likely a catch. If the player was falling, ask, “Was the fall part of the catch?” If yes, he must finish the catch on the ground. This simple routine makes sense to newcomers and removes the mystery.
Putting It All Together
Here is a simple way to think about it. A catch is not a single moment. It is a short story with three sentences: “He controlled it. He stayed in bounds. He acted like a ball carrier.” If the story is interrupted before the last sentence, it can still be incomplete. If the story is complete and then the ball comes out, it is a fumble—unless the runner was down. Near the sideline and in the end zone, the same story applies. If the player is still catching as he lands, he has to finish the story even while hitting the ground.
Conclusion
The catch rule is not magic. It is a checklist. Control the ball. Get the required feet or body parts in bounds. Do something a ball carrier would do—or have time to do it. If you are falling while catching, keep control through the landing unless you had already become a runner. With those ideas in mind, almost every play makes sense. The hardest part is catching all the details in real time. That is why replays focus on hands, feet, and time—and why the ruling on the field matters when camera angles are inconclusive.
Now, the next time a highlight shows a toe-tap at the sideline or a dive at the pylon, you will know exactly what to look for. You will see control start—or not. You will spot the second foot dragging—or missing. You will sense whether there was time for a football move. And instead of shouting “What is a catch?” you will be the one calmly explaining the rule while everyone else waits for the replay to confirm what you already know.