We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Football is a beautiful, fast, and emotional game, but it is also a game managed by human judgment. Referees are trained professionals who make hundreds of decisions each match under time pressure and in a crowded, high-speed environment. Sometimes they get it wrong. A missed call can be a foul not given, a penalty awarded harshly, an offside overlooked, or a handball seen differently by different people. For fans and newcomers to the sport, it can be confusing and frustrating. This article explains, in simple language, what missed calls are, why they happen, how they change a match, and what the sport is doing to reduce them.
We focus on association football (often called “soccer” in some countries). The goal is not to blame referees but to understand the pressures of officiating and the impact of errors. By the end, you will know how to watch with a sharper eye, how to judge incidents more fairly, and how to appreciate the balance between human judgment and technology in today’s game.
What We Mean by “Missed Call” in Football
A missed call is when the referee team—referee, assistant referees, and sometimes the video assistant referee (VAR)—does not make the correct decision according to the Laws of the Game. It can be something not called at all (a missed foul), something called incorrectly (a clean tackle punished as a foul), or a situation judged in a way that many believe is wrong. Not every mistake is obvious. Many calls are subjective, and reasonable people can disagree. That is part of why missed calls draw so much debate.
Common examples you will see
Typical missed calls include: a defender clips an attacker’s leg but the referee has a blocked view; a forward is slightly offside but the assistant’s angle makes it look onside; a handball in the penalty area that is accidental but still looks suspicious; a clear yellow card where the referee plays advantage and then forgets to caution; or added time that feels too short or too long. These are not signs of bias most of the time—they are the normal risks of judging moving events in real time.
Why missed calls matter more in a low-scoring game
Football is usually low-scoring, so one decision can decide the match. A wrongly given penalty often results in a goal. A disallowed goal for offside can erase a team’s best chance. A missed red card can let a dangerous player stay on the pitch. Because goals are rare, a single error can change the momentum, the tactics, and the outcome in ways that are harder to overcome than in high-scoring sports.
Why Referees Miss Calls
Human limits: angle, speed, and blocked views
Referees need the right angle to see contact. Two players can shield the ball and hide a trip or a shirt pull. The game moves quickly; players sprint, turn, and collide in a fraction of a second. Even with elite fitness, a referee might be 20 meters away at the wrong angle when the key contact happens. Unlike television, a referee cannot rewind or see multiple slow-motion angles in real time.
Positioning and teamwork within the crew
Referees work with assistant referees and, in many competitions, a fourth official and VAR. They plan their movement patterns to cover the field, but the ball can change direction instantly. Assistants focus on offside lines and may miss a foul behind the play. If communication breaks, the crew might hesitate—each expecting the other to make the call—and the moment passes.
Deception and simulation
Players try to win advantages. Some exaggerate contact or fall easily to draw a foul or penalty. Others hide small fouls by using their bodies cleverly. Simulation is difficult to spot in real time, especially when minimal contact exists. A realistic fall can sell a story that is hard to disprove at full speed, increasing the chance of an error.
Crowd and game context pressure
Referees are trained to resist pressure, but they are still human. A loud crowd, a heated rivalry, or a previous mistake can influence how confident a referee feels about the next call. Even the knowledge that a decision will be replayed and debated can create caution or overcorrection. Managing the game’s temperature becomes as important as getting every call perfect.
Judgment-based Laws of the Game
Many football laws are not black and white. What is “careless” versus “reckless”? What is the threshold for a handball being “unnatural”? What counts as denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity? These require interpretation. Two referees can apply the same law consistently but still make different decisions based on what they see and value in a particular moment.
Types of Calls That Most Often Go Wrong
Fouls and physical contact
Football allows shoulder-to-shoulder contact and fair challenges for the ball. The line between fair and foul is thin. A referee must decide whether contact caused the opponent to lose control or whether the attacker went down too easily. Mistakes often happen when the ball is touched first but the follow-through is dangerous, or when light contact appears heavier at speed.
Offside decisions
An attacker is offside if any part of their head, body, or feet is beyond the second-last defender when the ball is played, and they are involved in active play. This is hard to judge because it depends on two things happening at once: the exact moment the pass is made and the exact positions of players. Assistant referees must keep a perfect line while watching both the passer and the receiver. Tight calls are common sources of error without technology.
Handball interpretations
Handball decisions depend on whether the contact is deliberate, whether the arm position is natural for the action, and whether the player gained an unfair advantage. The same arm position may be natural for a defender jumping but unnatural for one sliding. The difficulty of handball law—updated often—makes it a frequent source of controversy and perceived missed calls.
Penalties and incidents in the box
Challenges in the penalty area are more closely judged because the punishment—a penalty kick—is huge. Small tugs, slight clips, and accidental trips happen in crowded spaces. A referee might hesitate to give a penalty for marginal contact, sometimes missing a clear foul. The opposite also happens: soft penalties given because a fall looked convincing. Either way, the impact can be decisive.
Advantage and stopping play
Referees can let play continue if the fouled team keeps a better opportunity. This is called advantage. If the advantage does not materialize, the referee can pull play back to the original foul. Misjudging advantage can look like a missed call: either stopping a promising attack too soon, or letting play go on when a free kick would have been better. Also, if a yellow card is needed after advantage, the referee must remember to caution at the next stoppage.
Timekeeping and added time
Referees keep the official time. They add time for injuries, substitutions, and delays. Fans often feel shortchanged if a team is pushing for a goal and little time is added. While there are guidelines, it is not a strict formula, so perception of unfairness is common. In big moments, added time choices can feel like missed calls.
Disciplinary decisions: yellow and red cards
Determining whether a foul is careless (no card), reckless (yellow), or using excessive force (red) requires a quick read of speed, point of contact, and danger. A second yellow leading to a red is especially sensitive. If a referee misjudges intensity or misses a key angle, players can be sent off or spared wrongly, changing the match dramatically.
How a Single Missed Call Can Change a Match
Momentum and psychology
Teams feed off energy. A wrongly disallowed goal can deflate attackers. A penalty against the run of play can energize the defending team. Players may lose trust in the referee and start arguing instead of focusing. This mental shift is often invisible in statistics but obvious to anyone watching the body language on the field.
Tactical ripple effects
Coaches adjust based on score and cards. If a team goes down to ten players because of a questionable red card, they may switch to a deep defensive block, inviting pressure and counterattacks. If a soft penalty puts one team ahead, the opponent might push fullbacks higher, creating space behind for the leading team to exploit. One decision can flip the chessboard of the match.
The first goal premium
In many matches, the first goal is decisive. It changes how both teams play. If a missed call affects who scores first, it can tilt the entire contest. The trailing team must chase the game, taking more risks. The leading team can control tempo and play safer passes. This is why early mistakes feel especially costly.
Player safety and future availability
Missing a red-card-worthy tackle can risk a player’s health. Conversely, sending someone off in error can remove them from a crucial match and affect future suspensions. Injuries or suspensions caused by missed calls can influence not only one match but a run of fixtures.
Beyond One Match: Season and Career Impacts
League tables and qualification
Points lost to missed calls may affect who wins a title, qualifies for continental competitions, or gets relegated. While teams have many matches to make up ground, a few key incidents across a season can tilt tight races. When margins are thin, refereeing errors can loom large in hindsight.
Transfers, contracts, and coaching jobs
Results change how clubs evaluate players and coaches. A supporter’s patience may run out after a run of unlucky decisions. A coach under pressure could lose a job after a controversial defeat. While this is harsh, it shows how the chain of consequences from a missed call travels beyond the pitch.
Club finances and reputations
Prize money, broadcast revenue, and sponsorships are linked to results and league position. A single call won’t make or break a club’s finances, but in a tight field, the accumulation of points affected by errors can influence revenue. Reputations also shift: teams labeled “divers” or “aggressive” may feel referees approach them differently over time, rightly or wrongly.
Case Studies You May Have Heard About
The “Hand of God” (1986)
In the 1986 World Cup quarterfinal, Diego Maradona scored with his hand against England, and the goal stood because the referee and assistants did not see the handball. It became one of the most famous missed calls in history. The moment defined the match, and it also influenced how fans and officials think about deception, positioning, and the need for better angles.
Goal-line controversy (2010)
In the 2010 World Cup, England’s Frank Lampard had a shot that crossed the goal line against Germany but was not given as a goal. Without goal-line technology at the time, the officials missed it. That high-profile error helped accelerate the adoption of goal-line technology, which now alerts referees instantly when the ball fully crosses the line.
Handball in qualifying (2009)
In a World Cup qualifying playoff between France and the Republic of Ireland, a handball in the buildup to a decisive goal went unpunished. The incident caused widespread debate about fairness and the need for video review in critical matches. It is often cited when discussing how a single missed call can affect a nation’s footballing fortunes.
Technology’s Role: Helping Without Replacing Humans
Goal-line technology (GLT)
GLT uses sensors and cameras to detect when the ball fully crosses the line. The referee’s watch vibrates to signal a goal. This has nearly eliminated one type of missed call: whether a goal should stand. It is quick, reliable, and minimally disruptive to the flow of the game.
VAR: when it can intervene
VAR exists to correct clear and obvious errors for goals, penalties, direct red cards, and cases of mistaken identity. The referee can review the incident on a pitchside monitor or accept advice from the VAR. Importantly, VAR is not for re-refereeing the whole match. Many subjective fouls remain on-field judgments unless there is a clear mistake.
Semi-automated offside technology
In some competitions, offside decisions are assisted by limb-tracking and calibrated cameras. The system helps draw offside lines more quickly and accurately. It reduces guesswork for ultra-tight calls, though the final interpretation still belongs to officials, especially when judging whether a player is “interfering” with play.
Limits and side effects
Technology introduces delays, changes celebrations, and can make fans feel that everything should be perfect. But many laws still require judgment. Slow motion can exaggerate contact or make a normal follow-through look dangerous. Technical lines on offside may be accurate but still feel unfair when margins are tiny. Technology helps, but it does not end debate.
Why errors still happen with VAR
VAR depends on camera angles, frame rates, and human interpretation. If the cameras do not capture the decisive contact clearly, or if the VAR does not consider an angle, mistakes can persist. Also, the “clear and obvious” standard means borderline calls are purposely left with the on-field decision to preserve the referee’s authority and keep the game flowing.
What Referees Do to Reduce Mistakes
Preparation and fitness
Top referees train as athletes. They practice sprinting, change of direction, and stamina to keep up with play. They study teams’ tactics to anticipate patterns—knowing, for example, which wingers cut inside or which forwards target the back post. Better anticipation means better positioning and fewer blind spots.
Communication and teamwork
Referees and assistants agree on signals and zones of responsibility. They use headsets in many leagues to share information instantly: “Wait, possible handball,” or “I have the offside line.” Clear communication prevents hesitation. After an advantage, reminders like “Yellow at the next stop” help keep discipline consistent.
Consistency and game management
Good referees set a clear standard early. If small shirt pulls are called as fouls from the first minutes, players adapt. Consistency reduces frustration and makes it easier to manage emotions on the pitch. Calm, confident body language and clear explanations also help players accept decisions, even when they disagree.
Post-match review and training
Officials review video, receive feedback from assessors, and study difficult incidents. They practice rare scenarios—like double touches on penalties or mass confrontations—so they are ready. The goal is continuous improvement, not perfection, because perfection is unrealistic in a dynamic sport.
What Players and Coaches Can Do
Play to the whistle and adapt quickly
The oldest advice is still the best: do not stop unless the referee stops play. If you think there was a foul, keep going until you hear the whistle. After a missed call, mature teams reset fast. They refocus, track runners, and execute the next play. Staying engaged prevents one bad moment from turning into two.
Manage emotions and discipline
Arguing can earn cards and distract from the game plan. Captains should be the main communicators with the referee. Calm questions—“What did you see?”—often get better responses than shouting. Discipline also reduces risk. Clean tackles, careful arms in the box, and smart body positioning give referees less to judge.
Tactical adjustments after a miss
If a teammate is wrongly booked early, the coach might protect them by adjusting roles or substituting to avoid a second yellow. If a soft penalty puts the team behind, a coach may switch to a more aggressive press or bring on a forward earlier. Treat the missed call as a new match state and adapt accordingly.
Respectful communication with officials
Referees are more open to listening when approached respectfully. A short explanation request helps both sides: it informs the team and builds a professional relationship. This does not guarantee decisions go your way, but it improves understanding and reduces the cycle of frustration.
How Fans and Media Shape the Conversation
Confirmation bias and slow-motion replays
Fans tend to see what supports their team. Slow motion can make a light touch look like a forceful blow, or a normal arm swing look deliberate. Watching incidents at full speed first, then in slow motion, leads to a fairer view. Recognizing our biases helps us discuss calls more calmly.
Social media pressure and abuse
Referees face intense online criticism, sometimes crossing into abuse. This harms the human beings behind the whistle and can drive good officials out of the game. Constructive analysis improves officiating; personal attacks do not. A healthier culture benefits players, referees, and fans alike.
Demanding transparency without vilifying people
Leagues are moving toward more transparency—publishing explanations, releasing audio in some cases, or admitting errors. This is good for trust. The challenge is to hold systems accountable while remembering that individuals are doing a difficult job under pressure.
Youth and Amateur Football: A Different Reality
No tech and fewer officials
Most matches worldwide have no VAR and sometimes only one referee. Missed calls are more common at these levels. The priorities are safety, learning, and enjoyment. Parents, coaches, and players can help by keeping perspective and showing respect. The environment should develop confidence for young referees and young players alike.
Teaching respect and resilience
Working through a bad call can teach valuable lessons: control what you can, move on quickly, and support teammates. Coaches can model good behavior by focusing on solutions rather than complaints. Over time, this mindset leads to better performance and better sportsmanship.
How to Watch a Match with a Referee’s Eye
Think about angles and proximity
When a challenge happens, ask yourself: where was the referee standing? Could they see the point of contact, or was it hidden? If the view was blocked, it is easier to understand why a decision might be missed or delayed.
Ask whether it was clear and obvious
Not every disagreement is an error. If, after seeing multiple angles, reasonable people could still disagree, then it is not truly “clear and obvious.” VAR is designed mainly for big, obvious mistakes on key incidents, not every gray area. This mindset helps manage expectations.
Understand expected foul thresholds
Referees often set a threshold for what counts as a foul in that match. If light contact has not been called all game, do not expect a last-minute penalty for similar contact. Look for consistency across the 90 minutes rather than perfection on each incident.
A Simple Framework for Judging Controversies
The four Ps: Position, Pace, Provability, Proportionality
Position: Could the referee see it clearly? If not, the chance of a miss increases. Pace: Did it happen at high speed with multiple moving parts? Faster moments are harder to call. Provability: Would video or other angles make the truth clear? If not, the call may remain subjective. Proportionality: Is the punishment appropriate for the action? For example, was a red card justified by the danger of the tackle? Using these four Ps helps structure your analysis and avoid emotional reactions.
The Future of Officiating
Data, wearables, and improved communication
Referees may use more data on running patterns, fatigue, and positioning to improve angles. Communication tools will get clearer and more secure. Education for players and fans will also expand, with more leagues publishing explanations of decisions and training clips to standardize understanding.
Global standards and consistent interpretation
The Laws of the Game are global, but interpretations can vary by league and culture. International efforts aim to align thresholds for handball, tackling force, and dissent. The more consistent the standards, the fewer surprises for players moving between leagues and the fewer controversies for fans.
Conclusion
Missed calls in football are inevitable because the sport is fast, complex, and heavily dependent on human judgment. They can change momentum, alter tactics, and sway results, especially in a low-scoring game where single moments matter. Technology like goal-line systems, VAR, and semi-automated offside has improved accuracy, but it has not and cannot remove every controversy, because many laws still rely on interpretation. The path forward is not to chase perfection, but to pursue improvement—better positioning, clearer communication, smarter use of technology, and more transparency.
Players and coaches can control their response: stay composed, adapt tactics, and communicate respectfully. Fans and media can help by reducing abuse and demanding accountability without vilifying people. At every level of the sport, from youth matches to the World Cup, the goal is the same: fair play decided by players, with referees guiding the contest safely and consistently. Understanding why missed calls happen and how they influence the game makes us all better participants in football’s ongoing story—more informed, more patient, and more appreciative of the human art at the heart of the world’s game.