We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Every October, when the games get louder and the lights get brighter, Major League Baseball chooses a small group of umpires to work the postseason. Fans often ask: how do those umpires get picked, and what makes them good enough for the sport’s biggest stage? The answers are both simple and surprisingly detailed. There is no magic list, and it is not just about one season’s hot hand. MLB uses year-long evaluation, modern tracking technology, old-school observation, and a deep focus on leadership to decide who earns those playoff assignments. This guide breaks down the selection process, the skills that matter, how crews are built for October, and what an umpire’s life looks like when every pitch matters a little more.
How Postseason Umpires Are Chosen
Who Makes the Call
The selection comes from MLB’s Umpiring Department in the Commissioner’s Office. This group oversees the full-time MLB umpiring staff from spring through the World Series. They watch games, grade calls, study data, talk with supervisors and crew chiefs, and review how umpires handle tough moments. When the regular season ends, they choose postseason crews based on the full body of work, not just a few headline plays.
When the Selections Happen
Crews are usually announced shortly before each round. Wild Card Series crews are set at the end of the regular season. Division Series crews follow soon after, and then the League Championship Series and World Series crews are named as the bracket advances. MLB does not release the exact scores or rankings behind the choices, but the announced crews reflect that year’s performance, health, and availability, along with experience and leadership needs.
Who Is Eligible
To work in October, an umpire must be a full-time MLB umpire in good standing and healthy enough to handle the travel and workload. While there is no hard rule that says “you must have X years of service,” experience is a big factor. Umpires who are new to the full-time staff will usually need time to build a track record. Veterans who have managed complex situations well through the year often rise on the list.
The Core Criteria MLB Looks At
Ball-Strike Accuracy and Consistency
Behind the plate, consistency is everything. MLB uses tracking tools to evaluate strike zones over the long run. These tools, which use pitch location data, help confirm what the eyes already see: who is steady night after night. October assignments favor umpires who call a tight, predictable zone and adjust smoothly to different pitchers and hitters. One game does not define an umpire, but months of data do.
Safe-Out, Fair-Foul, and Boundary Calls
On the bases and down the lines, angles and timing matter. MLB grades umpires on footwork, positioning, and the ability to see the whole play, from tag to touch. In the postseason, the mechanics change because there are six umpires on the field. That means more eyes on tough plays—especially fair/foul decisions near the poles and home-run boundary calls at the wall. Umpires who excel with angles and patient timing stand out in the selection process.
Replay Performance
Modern evaluation includes how often an umpire’s calls are affirmed or overturned on replay. A raw overturn number does not tell the whole story, because some umpires face more close, high-speed plays than others. MLB looks at the quality of decisions, how the umpire applied the rules, and whether the on-field crew managed the review process correctly and professionally.
Game Management and Communication
October games bring louder crowds, bigger stakes, and hotter benches. MLB values umpires who keep the game under control without becoming the show. Calm signals, clear explanations, and professional conversations with managers are all part of the grade. The best postseason umpires know when to listen, when to warn, when to eject, and how to explain a ruling so both sides can move on.
Rules Knowledge and Judgment
The baseball rulebook includes dozens of complex situations, from obstruction and interference to time plays, appeals, and boundary quirks. Postseason umpires must be fluent in the rules and the official interpretations. In October, one missed nuance can decide a game. Umpires who show clean, confident judgment under pressure move up the list.
Fitness and Availability
Even in cool fall weather, postseason baseball is physically demanding. Plate work requires strength and flexibility; base work requires quick bursts, sharp cuts, and long concentration. MLB considers injuries and general fitness when assigning rounds. An umpire might have the résumé for October, but if he is not fully healthy, the league will go with someone ready to go the distance.
Experience and Leadership
Experience matters most when things get messy. Many postseason crews include a veteran crew chief who has managed complicated situations before. The chief sets expectations, keeps the crew ready, and is the primary voice during disputes and rules checks. Young umpires still make the postseason, but key leadership roles often go to proven veterans.
The Different Rounds and Crew Sizes
Wild Card Series
The Wild Card Series opens the postseason with best-of-three matchups. MLB assigns a six-umpire crew to each series. That means four umpires around the infield and two umpires down the lines in left and right field. With six on the field, line calls and boundary plays are covered more thoroughly than in the regular season.
Division Series
The Division Series uses the same six-umpire setup. Because there are multiple series happening at once, MLB needs a large pool of qualified umpires. This is where depth matters. Some umpires will work in the Wild Card round and the Division Series; others might be held for later rounds depending on performance, health, and the league’s internal planning.
League Championship Series
By the LCS, the league wants its most reliable crews. These umpires have shown accuracy and poise all year and often have postseason experience. The six-umpire mechanics continue, and assignments within the series are planned so that each umpire can contribute where he is strongest, with the rotation giving everyone a fair share of key positions.
World Series
The World Series crew is a select group. MLB often uses a six-umpire field crew plus a designated replay official who may rotate onto the field after the early games. The plate is a prized assignment, and the crew chief is usually given a central role. Plate assignments are arranged so that, if the series goes the distance, each umpire can carry a major responsibility while also balancing rest and recovery.
Replay Officials and Reserves
Postseason reviews are handled from MLB’s Replay Operations Center, with assigned umpires serving as replay officials. In some rounds, a reserve umpire may be on hand to step in if there is an injury. These behind-the-scenes roles are part of the postseason honor too, and they require strong rules knowledge and a calm, decisive approach.
Inside a Postseason Umpiring Crew
The Crew Chief’s Role
The crew chief is the captain. He leads the pre-series and pre-game meetings, sets standard signals, coordinates with MLB on logistics, and is the first point of contact for managers and the broadcast team. When a protestable situation or complex rules play arises, the chief gathers the group, clarifies the rule, and ensures the final answer is clear and correct.
Rotation and Plate Assignments
Within a series, umpires rotate through the positions. While the exact pattern can vary, the goal is balance: everyone works the plate and the bases, and the two outfield umpires cover both corners over the course of the series. If a series ends early, some umpires may not reach every position, but the plan is designed to spread the pressure and keep the crew sharp.
Six-Umpire Mechanics
Postseason mechanics are not just a regular-season game with two extra people. With six umpires, there are dedicated eyes on fair/foul line calls near the poles, deeper coverage on potential home runs, and stronger angles on deep outfield catches and tag-ups. The infield umpires can hold better positions for time plays and rundowns. Every member knows where to move on balls in the gap, double steals, and choppers with a runner breaking home.
Pre-Game Preparation and Ground Rules
Before the first pitch, the crew holds a detailed meeting. They review the teams’ tendencies, the ballpark’s ground rules, and any recent rules clarifications from MLB. Every park has unique quirks—fences, rails, nooks, ladders, camera wells—and the crew must agree exactly how to judge balls that hit or clear those areas. Umpires also coordinate with the teams on lineup cards, challenge procedures, and any weather plans.
Communication on the Field
Silent signals, eye contact, and timing are the language of a good crew. With six umpires, communication prevents double calls, confusion on check-swings, or missed responsibilities on a deep drive. When a call is close, a simple look to a partner can confirm whether a catch was clean or trapped. When there is a conference, the crew chief makes sure the umpire with the best look speaks first. Clarity keeps the game moving and protects the integrity of the call.
Life Off the Field in October
Travel and Schedules
Postseason travel is set by the bracket. Umpires move between cities on tight timelines, sometimes working late nights and day games with only a quick turnaround. MLB handles logistics such as flights and hotels so the crew can focus on preparation and recovery. During travel days, crews hold shorter meetings, review unusual plays from the last game, and reset the rotation if needed.
Pay, Bonuses, and Professional Pride
Postseason assignments come with extra compensation beyond the regular season. The details are covered by MLB’s agreements with the umpires’ union, and include per diems, travel support, and bonus pay. Money aside, October assignments are a career milestone. Working a postseason round is an honor; working a World Series is a legacy moment that can lead to future leadership roles.
Mental Preparation and Recovery
October pressure is real, and so is October fatigue. Umpires use film review, quiet routines, and physical recovery to stay sharp. That might mean studying a team’s bunt tendencies, getting a feel for sliders vs. cutters from the day’s starters, or noting how a particular catcher sets up on the corners. Hydration, stretching, and short workouts keep the body ready for long innings in cool weather.
Dealing With Scrutiny
Every pitch is tracked on television. Social media posts and graphics fly right after close calls. The best umpires accept that noise, then tune it out. Their focus is the next pitch, not the last replay. MLB supports crews with internal feedback and guidance so a single controversy does not define their approach to the rest of the series.
The Path to October
From the Minors to the Majors
Almost every MLB umpire started in the minors. The path runs through umpire schools, then low-level leagues, then up the ladder year by year. Umpires are scouted and graded constantly. After years of development, a prospect might become a Triple-A umpire who gets “call-up” games in MLB. Only after proving reliability over many assignments does a call-up earn a full-time MLB spot.
Building a Track Record
Once on the staff, an umpire builds a file that grows every season. The file includes plate scores, replay stats, observer reports, handling of disputes, crew feedback, and health. Consistency across different parks, travel stretches, and high-stress games tells MLB that the umpire can bring the same standard to October.
Becoming a Crew Chief
Crew chief promotions come to umpires who combine performance with leadership. Chiefs must know the mechanics for every position, explain complex rules, manage lively clubhouses, and mentor less experienced partners. Postseason work helps a candidate show he can lead on the sport’s largest stage.
Technology’s Role in October
Replay: What It Is and What It Is Not
Replay helps get more calls right, but it does not replace on-field judgment. Managers have challenge opportunities under strict timing rules, and certain plays are reviewable. Others, like balls and strikes and most check-swings, are not reviewable. Postseason replay is quick and structured, with the stadium crew coordinating headsets and the Replay Operations Center delivering a final ruling after a short review.
Pitch Timer, Mound Visits, and New Rules
The pitch timer and limits on disengagements and mound visits add new responsibilities for umpires. In October, they enforce the same rules as in April. The difference is that crews must balance strict enforcement with the postseason’s unique rhythm. MLB expects calls to be consistent year-round, and postseason umpires are chosen partly because they handle these rules firmly and fairly.
Automated Ball-Strike Systems: The Ongoing Conversation
Automated ball-strike systems (ABS) have been tested in the minors, and the debate about the major league zone continues. As of now, MLB postseason plates are called by human umpires. If ABS ever comes to the majors, it will change how plate performance is graded, but not the need for leadership, rules knowledge, and in-game management. Until then, the human zone remains a core skill for October selection.
Common Myths About Postseason Umpires
Myth: Only the Oldest Umpires Get the Big Games
Experience matters, but age is not the ticket. MLB blends veterans and newer standouts. A younger umpire with a strong season, clean replay record, and top plate consistency can earn a playoff spot, while an older umpire recovering from injury may not. The mix changes every year.
Myth: It Is All About the Plate Score
The plate is vital, but MLB’s view is wider. Base work, boundary calls, positioning, communication, and rules handling all count. Some umpires are elite on the bases and bring tremendous value to a postseason crew even if they are not the top-rated plate caller that season.
Myth: Hometown Bias Plays a Role
Umpires do not work based on where they live or grew up. MLB tries to minimize even the appearance of conflicts. The assignments are built around performance, health, and scheduling—not local ties. Professionalism and neutrality are core expectations.
Myth: One Bad Call Ends Your October
Nobody likes a miss, especially in a huge spot. But MLB evaluates the whole picture. If an umpire handles the next innings calmly, makes strong calls overall, and communicates well, a single miss does not erase months of top-level work. Learning and bouncing back are key traits.
What Makes a Great October Umpire
Composure Under Fire
The crowd is roaring, the bases are loaded, and the manager is yelling. A great October umpire keeps his heartbeat steady and his voice even. He signals clearly, listens briefly, and moves the game forward with confidence. Composure sets the tone for the whole field.
Angles and Timing
Mechanics are physics in motion. The best umpires move early, plant their feet, and see the tag and the touch in one frame. They wait that extra beat so the brain can confirm what the eyes saw, then they call it. Good timing makes close plays feel correct even to the losing dugout.
Consistency Pitch to Pitch
Hitters and pitchers can adjust to almost any zone if it is steady. The great plate umpire delivers the same strike at 1:05 p.m. that he calls at 11:45 p.m., no matter who is on the mound. That trust keeps the game fair and the temperature down when the stakes are highest.
Teamwork and a Crew-First Mindset
October crews function as one. Partners back each other up on steals, choppers, and sinking liners. They share information quickly and honestly. No ego, no showmanship, just a group working to get plays right. MLB rewards umpires who build that kind of crew culture all season.
How Assignments Inside a Series Are Decided
Balancing Strengths
Before the series, MLB and the crew chief map out a rotation that balances skills and workload. If an umpire is exceptional on the bases, he may open the series at a key infield position. A plate specialist might take Game 1 or a potential clincher. The rotation also accounts for recovery needs; working the plate is physically and mentally demanding, so spacing matters.
Handling Injuries or Changes
If an umpire is injured or becomes ill, the crew adjusts. A reserve or replay-designated umpire can step in, and the rotation shifts so all positions stay covered. These changes are handled quietly and professionally so the game itself remains the focus.
A Day in the Life: Postseason Edition
Morning and Early Afternoon
Umpires hydrate, stretch, and review notes. They might watch clips of borderline pitches for that day’s starters or look at a team’s squeeze play from last week. If they are traveling, the morning might be a flight and then a quick rest at the hotel. The mantra is simple: move, fuel, and learn one or two useful things—not a full cram session.
Late Afternoon to First Pitch
At the stadium, the crew conducts its final meeting. They review ground rules with managers, check the headsets and replay procedures, and confirm the rotation. Gear checks are surprisingly detailed: mask, chest protector, shin guards, plate shoes or base shoes, and layers for weather. As the crowd fills in, the crew visualizes key plays and positions one more time.
During the Game
It is all focus. Plate umpires lock in on release points and catcher setups. Base umpires anticipate bunt coverage, pickoffs, and back-picks. Line umpires watch the slices and hooks that can turn a fair ball into a foul ball by inches. During breaks, short huddles keep everyone aligned on rotations and signals.
Postgame
The crew cools down, rehydrates, and reviews any unusual plays. If a manager requested a rule explanation, the chief confirms the interpretation. Everyone resets for the next day. In the postseason, great crews never carry yesterday’s tension into today’s game.
What Fans Can Watch For in October
Rotations and Angles
On extra-base hits, watch how the infield umpires rotate and how the outfield umpires close to the line. You will see a carefully rehearsed dance designed to create the best angles. When it is done well, close plays look less controversial because the umpire is exactly where he should be.
Signals and Conferences
Small gestures say a lot. A tap of the chest might confirm who has the catch/no-catch responsibility. A point to a partner can indicate help on a swipe tag. If the crew gathers, notice that the person with the best view speaks first. That discipline is taught and reinforced all year.
Replay Windows
When a manager signals for a hold, the clock is ticking. You can track how quickly a team decides to challenge and how smoothly the crew connects with the replay room. The cleanest reviews keep the game tempo steady, which is a quiet sign of a quality crew.
Why October Assignments Matter for Umpires
Career Milestones
Postseason work reflects trust from the league. It helps an umpire earn consideration for future leadership roles and strengthens his reputation among peers. A World Series assignment is the pinnacle—often recognized with a ring and remembered throughout a career.
Raising the Standard for Everyone
Umpires who make October set the bar for their colleagues. Their season-long habits—preparation, positioning, clear signals, and composure—become the model for younger umpires moving up the ladder. In that sense, October is both a reward and a teaching tool for the profession.
A Simple Example: From Regular Season to Postseason
Building the Case Across 162 Games
Imagine an umpire who posts steady plate numbers, takes smart angles on steals and pickoffs, and handles two heated benches without letting the game spin out. His replay numbers are strong, and his crew chief notes that teammates trust his judgment. By September, the Umpiring Department sees the pattern: reliable plate, clean bases, and professional communication. That profile often equals a call for the Wild Card or Division Series.
From One Round to the Next
If the same umpire delivers in the Division Series—calm, clean calls, good teamwork—he becomes a candidate for the LCS or a future World Series. Not every strong umpire moves round by round in the same year; health, scheduling, and overall staffing needs also matter. But the principle holds: consistent excellence opens postseason doors.
What It Takes to Be Ready on Day One
Know the Book, Know the Park
The rulebook is step one. Step two is the ground rules for the specific park. Postseason umpires study where a ball is live or dead, how a railing affects a catch, and how fan interference is judged in that stadium. They also align on positioning so two umpires do not chase the same fly ball down the line.
Trust the Crew
Preparation includes agreeing on who will take what if a unique play occurs. With two on and one out, what if the runner breaks for home on a sharp grounder? If there is a double steal, who has the play at third if the throw gets through? These what-if checks build trust. When the ball is hit, nobody hesitates.
Stay in the Moment
The crowd is loud and the game is huge, but the best umpires keep their world small: the baseball, the runners, the next pitch. That mindset makes October feel like any other game, and that is often the secret to performing well when everything is on the line.
Final Checks Before First Pitch
Equipment and Comfort
Plate umpires confirm their mask fit, throat guard, and lens clarity. Base umpires adjust shoes for better traction on cool, damp nights. Layers are planned so movement stays free. Little details—like keeping hands warm for quick signals—can make a real difference.
Communication With Teams
The crew reviews special ground rules with both managers and confirms how challenge requests will be signaled. If there is a tarp decision in the forecast, everyone understands the steps. Clear pregame communication reduces arguments later.
How Postseason Selection Is Different From the Regular Season
Fewer Slots, Higher Stakes
There are only so many October assignments. Even good umpires may miss out in a given year because MLB needs a specific mix of skills or because of injuries. The smaller number of games means only the most trusted umpires get the nod, especially in the later rounds.
Leadership Weight Increases
In April, a high plate score speaks loudly. In October, leadership speaks even louder. MLB wants crew chiefs and senior umpires who can prevent small disagreements from becoming big delays. Calm leaders keep postseason baseball crisp and fair.
Key Takeaways for New Fans
Multiple Factors Decide October Crews
It is not just about strike zones or replay stats. MLB weighs accuracy, mechanics, management, rules knowledge, leadership, health, and teamwork. October umpires are complete professionals, not just specialists.
Six Umpires Improve Coverage
The extra eyes help on fair/foul, home run boundaries, and deep outfield plays. Good mechanics and communication help get more calls right the first time.
Preparation Shows Up in Small Ways
Watch how quickly a crew aligns on quirky plays or complex rules. That smoothness comes from meetings, study, and thousands of reps. Postseason crews do not guess; they anticipate.
Conclusion
What It Takes to Officiate in October
Being selected to umpire in the MLB postseason is about trust earned over time. The league looks for accuracy, consistency, and calm leadership. It values the umpires who make tough calls look routine, who manage heated moments with steady hands, and who know the rulebook so well that chaotic plays become clear. Technology supports the process, but teamwork and judgment still decide most of what fans see.
Why It Matters
The postseason is baseball at its highest level. Players chase a title, managers push every edge, and fans live and die with each pitch. Umpires are there to keep that drama fair. When MLB chooses its October crews, it is choosing guardians of the game. Those selections reflect months of evaluation and years of experience, all aimed at one goal: a postseason where the players decide the outcome and the umpires help the game shine.