We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Baseball keeps score with fine detail, and few entries spark more debate than the error. Fans argue about it. Players feel it. Pitchers watch their ERA change because of it. Understanding what an error is, how it is scored, and how it shapes both offense and defense will help you read the game with clarity. This guide breaks down the concept step by step, links it to scoring rules and stats, and gives you practical examples you can spot in real time.
What an Error Means in Baseball
An error is a defensive misplay that allows a batter or runner to reach a base or take an extra base when an average fielder, using ordinary effort, would have made the play. The key is ordinary effort. Not perfect effort. Not a highlight reel play. The official scorer judges whether a routine play should have been completed and whether the misplay directly changed the outcome of the play.
Errors are charged to individual fielders. They appear in the box score as E for the team and as a counting stat for each defender. Errors do not credit the batter with a hit. They can change whether runs are earned or unearned. They also influence traditional defensive stats such as fielding percentage.
The Ordinary Effort Standard
The ordinary effort standard keeps errors from being handed out on every hard play. If a shortstop dives into the hole and bobbles a rocket, that is usually not an error. If the same shortstop boots a routine grounder, that is an error. If an outfielder camps under a fly ball and drops it, that is an error. If the outfielder sprints full speed into the gap and the ball tips off the glove, that is usually a hit.
Official scorers rely on experience and context. Ball speed, distance, angle, footing, sun, and wind all matter. The test is whether an average fielder at that position should make the play with routine effort. When in doubt on a tough play, scorers tend to call it a hit rather than an error.
Types of Errors
Fielding errors
These occur when a fielder mishandles the ball on a catch or a ground ball. Common examples include:
– Booting a routine grounder that should have been an out
– Dropping a fly ball that was settled under and catchable with ordinary effort
– Failing to field a throw that arrives in time when the catch should be routine
On scorecards, errors are noted with the position number of the fielder. E6 means an error by the shortstop. E3 means an error by the first baseman.
Throwing errors
These occur when a fielder makes a bad throw that allows a runner to advance or reach. Examples include:
– A third baseman throws wide of first base and the batter reaches
– An outfielder airmails the cutoff and a runner takes an extra base
– A middle infielder rushes a relay and throws it into the dugout
When a throw goes out of play, runners may be awarded extra bases by rule. The scorer credits a throwing error to the defender whose throw caused the award.
Dropped catches and tag plays
A dropped catch that should have been completed is an error, whether the drop happens on a force at a base, a throw that beats the runner, or a tag where the ball was secured and then lost on the tag attempt. If the throw is wild and forces the receiver into a tough reach, the throwing fielder takes the error. If the throw is on target and the receiver drops it, the receiving fielder takes the error.
Catcher interference
When the catcher hinders the batter during the swing and the batter is awarded first base, the catcher is charged with an error. This is a specific case where the rules assign an error automatically. Obstruction by other fielders that results in awards is handled by rule and is not scored as an error.
Multiple errors on one play
More than one error can occur on the same play. A shortstop can boot a grounder and then throw wildly, earning two errors as the batter reaches and then advances. Different fielders can also make separate errors during the same sequence. Each misplay that grants an otherwise unearned base counts as its own error.
What is not an error
– A tough play not made with extraordinary effort is not an error
– A fielder choosing to attempt a play on a lead runner and not getting anyone out is not automatically an error if an out at first would not have been certain
– A ball lost in the sun or wind that is not touched is usually scored a hit
– Passed balls and wild pitches are not errors, even though runners advance
– Defensive indifference, where the defense does not contest a steal, is not an error
How Errors Are Scored
Position numbers and notation
Baseball uses standard numbers for defensive positions to simplify scorekeeping:
– 1 pitcher
– 2 catcher
– 3 first base
– 4 second base
– 5 third base
– 6 shortstop
– 7 left field
– 8 center field
– 9 right field
Errors are logged with E and the number of the fielder. E5 means an error by the third baseman. In a box score, the team error column shows the total number of player errors committed by that team in the game.
Runner advancement on errors
The scorer credits a base or extra base to a runner only if the error directly allowed the advance that would not have happened with ordinary play. A batter who reaches first on an error has reached on error. If that same misplay also allows the batter to take second, the scorer may charge one error if both the reach and the advance are part of the same misplay, or two errors if separate misplays occur, such as a fielding bobble followed by a throwing error. On overthrows into dead ball territory, base awards apply, and the throwing fielder gets a throwing error.
If a runner would have advanced even with flawless defense, the scorer does not credit an extra base to the error. For example, a runner going first to third on a clean single does not get an extra base on a harmless bobble that did not affect the outcome.
Reconstructing the inning for earned runs
Errors matter for earned runs. To decide if runs are earned, the scorer reconstructs the inning as if the defense had made all ordinary plays. If an error should have ended the inning and runs score afterward, those runs are unearned. If a batter reaches on error and later scores, that run is unearned unless events after the error would have scored the runner anyway without the error.
Even if the pitcher commits the error, the run can still be unearned. Earned run average excludes unearned runs. This is why pitchers pay close attention to errors and why scorekeeping can affect ERA.
Special cases you should know
– Fielder choice: If a fielder tries for a lead runner and all runners end up safe, the scorer judges whether an out at first would have been routine. If not, no error is charged. If the fielder could have taken the sure out and failed due to a misplay, an error may be charged.
– Sacrifice bunt: If the batter bunts to advance a runner and would have been retired at first with ordinary effort, but a misplay allows all to be safe, the batter is credited with a sacrifice and the fielder is charged with an error.
– Sacrifice fly: If a fly ball deep enough to score a runner is dropped, the batter may be credited with a sacrifice fly, and the fielder can be charged with an error for allowing the batter to reach base.
– Dropped third strike: When strike three is not caught, the batter can try for first. The advance is scored as a passed ball or wild pitch, not an error. If an error occurs afterward on a throw or tag, that separate misplay can be charged as an error.
– Pickoffs and rundowns: If a throw beats the runner but is muffed at a base, the receiving fielder is charged with an error. If the pickoff throw is wild and the runner takes a base, the throwing fielder gets a throwing error.
Errors and Offensive Stats
Reach on error and batting average
Reaching on error is not a hit. It counts as an at bat unless the play qualifies as a sacrifice. Batting average does not include times reached on error. This protects hitters from being penalized for defensive mistakes, but it also does not reward them with hits for balls that should have been outs.
On base percentage and slugging
On base percentage does not include reaching on error. Slugging percentage counts total bases from hits only, so reaching or advancing on an error does not add to slugging. The batter does get credited with a time on base in game logs, but not in the OBP formula.
RBI rules related to errors
Runs that score primarily because of an error usually do not produce a run batted in for the batter. If the scorer judges that the run would have scored even without the error, such as on a deep fly or a hard grounder with two outs, an RBI can be credited. The principle matches earned run logic: credit the offense for runs expected without the misplay and avoid credit when the error is the reason the run scored.
No hitters and perfect games
Errors do not count as hits. A pitcher can allow baserunners by error and still complete a no hitter. A perfect game requires that no batter reaches base by any means, so a single error can end a perfect game even if hits remain at zero. This contrast highlights how defensive support and scoring decisions can shape the story of a pitching performance.
Errors and Defensive Stats
Fielding percentage limits
Fielding percentage is calculated as putouts plus assists divided by putouts plus assists plus errors. It captures how often a fielder converts chances without committing errors. It does not capture range or positioning. A fielder with limited range may make fewer errors because fewer balls become chances. This is why error totals alone do not define defensive quality.
Passed balls and wild pitches
Catchers have separate stats for passed balls. Pitchers have wild pitches. Neither is an error, but both can allow runners to advance and both affect earned runs in the same way an error does when reconstructing the inning. Understanding these categories avoids confusion when scoring a play like strike three in the dirt or a fastball that skips past the catcher.
Advanced metrics context
Modern evaluation leans on metrics that estimate outs above average, defensive runs saved, and zone based performance. These metrics measure how often a fielder converts opportunities of varying difficulty. They do not rely solely on errors. Errors remain part of the record and matter for certain outcomes, but they are only one piece of defensive value.
Reading a Box Score
Team errors column
The E column in a box score shows how many errors a team committed in the game. That count is the sum of the errors charged to individual players. A clean game with zero errors is common at the highest levels, and even one error can swing an inning by extending it.
Player fielding lines
Individual fielders carry season stats such as games, chances, putouts, assists, and errors. A shortstop with a high number of chances may also have more errors simply because of volume. When reading a fielding line, consider position difficulty and innings played along with error totals.
Strategy and Coaching
Risk management on defense
Teams balance aggressive throws with sure outs. On a slow roller, a third baseman may pocket the ball to prevent an error rather than force a rushed throw that likely pulls the first baseman off the bag. On a relay to the plate, a strong accurate throw can save a run, but a wild throw can award extra bases. Coaches set expectations by game situation, score, and scouting.
Communication and positioning
Many errors trace to miscommunication. Outfielders calling for a ball, middle infielders coordinating on pop ups, and relays with clear cut responsibilities all reduce misplays. Positioning also matters. Good pre pitch alignment turns fringe plays into ordinary plays. The more often a ball becomes ordinary, the lower the error risk.
Practicing routine plays
Defense at every level emphasizes routine plays. Clean footwork to the ball. Setting the feet on throws. Targeting the chest on relays. Rehearsing tags and exchanges around the bag. The goal is to make ordinary effort automatic so that errors rarely appear on routine contact.
Trends and Context
Changing standards
Error rates have declined over time as fields improved, equipment advanced, and training emphasized fundamentals. Official scorers also stay cautious on difficult plays, favoring hits when the difficulty level rises. This does not reduce the importance of errors, but it places them within a modern baseline where routine plays are expected to be converted at a high rate.
Ballpark and conditions
Conditions influence the ordinary effort standard. Day games can create tough sun angles for outfielders. Night games under lights can produce different reads. Wet infields add hops and footing issues. Official scorers consider these factors when judging whether a play should be made by an average defender.
How Scorers Decide: A Checklist
Use this quick checklist to evaluate a close call the way a scorer does:
– Was the ball playable with ordinary effort for that position
– Did the misplay directly allow a batter or runner to reach or advance
– Was the throw or catch routine, or did difficulty make it unlikely
– On a choice play, would a sure out have been routine somewhere else
– Did separate misplays occur, justifying multiple errors
– Did any awards come from rules such as catcher interference or base awards on overthrows
If the answer to ordinary effort and direct causation is yes, an error is likely. If difficulty or choice removes the routine outcome, a hit or a fielder choice without an error is more likely.
Clear Examples You Can Spot
– Routine grounder to short, bobbled, batter safe at first. E6
– Accurate throw from third arrives in time, first baseman drops it. E3
– Hard grounder deep in the hole, throw late even with a clean field. Infield hit, no error
– Fly ball to shallow left, outfielder camped under it and drops it. E7
– Outfielder sprints into the gap, full extension, ball tips off the glove. Hit, no error
– Catcher interferes with the swing, batter awarded first. E2
– Strike three in the dirt, batter reaches first as the ball gets by. Passed ball or wild pitch, not an error
– Infielder boots a ball, then throws it into the dugout. Two errors, E4 fielding and E4 throwing, with base awards on the overthrow
– Third baseman chooses to throw to second on a sharp grounder, lead runner safe, batter also safe, and an out at first would not have been routine. Fielder choice, no error
How Errors Shape the Score
A single error can flip an inning. A two out error that should have ended the frame gives the offense new life. Any runs that score after that point can be unearned. A routine throw that sails into the seats can turn a single into two bases and put the tying run in scoring position. These are not just accounting details. They change strategy, pitch selection, and the way managers deploy the bullpen.
Errors also mark a psychological line. Good defenses limit extra outs. Good pitchers push through when an error happens, bearing down on the next hitter. Scorers do not change their standards for pressure, but players feel the moment. Knowing the scoring logic helps you separate the cause from the effect and understand which outcomes trace to the misplay and which do not.
Putting Errors in Perspective
Errors are part of the record, but not the whole truth about defense. A slick fielder with great range may commit a few extra errors while getting to balls others never touch. A first baseman who scoops low throws prevents throwing errors for teammates. Catchers who block well lower passed balls and wild pitches that never show up as errors. When you evaluate defense, take the full picture: chances, difficulty, range, and how often routine plays stay routine.
Conclusion
An error in baseball is simple in principle and nuanced in practice. It is the misplay that turns an ordinary out or routine base control into extra offense. Scorers apply the ordinary effort test, charge the fielder whose misplay directly changed the play, and separate errors from passed balls and wild pitches. Errors influence earned runs, RBI credit, and the narrative of pitching lines, but they do not define defensive quality by themselves. With the framework in this guide, you can watch a game, spot the crucial details, and read the box score with confidence.
FAQ
Q: What is an error in baseball
A: An error is a defensive misplay that lets a batter or runner reach or advance when an average fielder using ordinary effort would have made the play.
Q: When is a misplayed ball not an error
A: A misplay is not an error when the play required more than ordinary effort, when a choice play did not have a sure out, or when the ball was not touched and was difficult due to factors like sun or wind.
Q: Do passed balls and wild pitches count as errors
A: No. Passed balls are charged to the catcher and wild pitches to the pitcher. They are separate from errors, though they affect earned runs in similar ways when reconstructing the inning.
Q: How do errors affect earned runs and ERA
A: Scorers reconstruct the inning without errors. If runs score that would not have scored with ordinary plays, those runs are unearned and do not count toward ERA, even if the pitcher made the error.
Q: Does reaching on an error count as a hit or help OBP
A: No. Reaching on error is not a hit and does not count in on base percentage. It is an at bat unless the play is scored as a sacrifice.